scroll the header off the screen
scroll the header off the screen
scroll the header off the screen
scroll the header off the screen
scroll the header off the screen
  logo scroll the header off the screen
scroll the header off the screen
scroll the header off the screen
scroll the header off the screen
scroll the header off the screen
 
HOME: 06-07, info, history, people, misc, Links | SHOP | Calendar | Table | Stats | FAQs | HELP

ArseWeb home Newsreel (Latest)
Other News
News links
Newsreel help
Newsreel FAQs
Newsreel topics
Latest
Search

news topic: Other news FAQ previous story...
 For gob's sake! (a call for perspective) by Rupe
on 5/10/99 at 12:01
this is story 183 of 532 in this topic to date
I know this is going to be controversial but I'm wondering if all this nonsense about Vieira's spitting at Ruddock has gotten out of hand.

Let me just make it clear that I don't want to be seen to be defending Vieira's actions. Clearly he did wrong. Clearly it is an ucky and offensive thing to do and he should be punished.

But isn't it time someone pointed out that the reaction to incidents like this is always out of proportion to the harm inflicted (ie none)? Today I see the Mirror carries the headline "HE'S SCUM", using Neil Ruddocks's words about Patrick Vieira. Ruddock says "What he did was scum. He is scum. He did the worst of all things." In the Mirror's own words Vieira has "broken the last taboo" and "the shame will lurk alongside him for the rest of his career".

Yes, gob is not a very pleasant substance to find being propelled towards ones face. Yes, there is no defence for it. But "the worst of all things"? Come off it, Neil. Is it really worse than deliberately fouling a player, in such a way as to produce a career threatening injury? Would Ruddock really have preferred it if Vieira had just stepped up and belted him? Let's not forget that Vieira was reacting to Ruddock's charging in to get involved in something that was nothing to do with him: a fact which seems to have escaped most commentators. See our match reports page for list of links to other sites reports, including some at least with a sense of balance (as well as our own match reports, naturally).

Footballers regularly do far more damaging things to each other, things intended to harm in ways that a bit of spit never could. And yet almost nothing ever produces the same kind of outcry as a bit of ballistic phlegm.

I'm reminded of the World Cup a few years back, when there was outrage at Frank Rijkard's spitting at Rudi Voller, and yet it was (allegedly) Voller's own racist remarks that caused the incident and that got much less coverage. Is spitting really worse than racism?

The Mirror calls it "the last taboo". Well, taboos are there to be broken, and the only way is to make it so commonplace that these kind of over-the-top reactions become absurd.

So I say, "let the gobbing commence".

and if you want to complain about the Mirror's coverage the address for the author of today's article is John Dillon, Mirro Sport, MGN, 1 Canada Square, Canary Wharf, London, or you could try emailing him c/o online@mgn.co.uk

 in this topic... Next story...
  Most recent story...
  FAQ for related info & links...
Newsreel contains 5411 searchable news articles,
going back to December 1998
Search Keyword(s)
* finds all stories

between and
use dd/mm/yy format (NewsReel goes back to 04/12/98)
See Full Search for usage help and more options.

If you find any broken links to ArseWeb pages,
please report them, thank you.


 in-topic context...
 Another Clash at Highbury?
13/10 at 01:34
 Wenger says hit Ruddock too!
12/10 at 11:23
 And you thought we had a discipline problem!
11/10 at 10:18
 Petit's on the web
8/10 at 12:35
 Ferguson's crap story convinces judge
5/10 at 13:30
 For gob's sake! (a call for perspective)
5/10 at 12:01
 Vieira charged by FA, and apologises
4/10 at 16:53
 Man United in court: GUILTY!
1/10 at 16:17
 Arsene's in gambling mood
27/9 at 12:54
 Leeds sign with Nike
17/9 at 11:00
 Keep taking the penalties, Kanu...
16/9 at 17:59
 See below for entries around this date in other news topics, or here for latest.
 Squad news 4/10/99 at 13:31
 Transfers 1/10/99 at 12:01
 Tickets/fixtures 4/10/99 at 12:46
 UK TV/radio 28/9/99 at 11:11
 non-UK TV 2/9/99 at 23:48
 Stadium news 20/9/99 at 11:40
 Premiership news 3/10/99 at 20:21
 European news 30/9/99 at 11:08
 ArseWeb news 5/10/99 at 13:10
 Lads & Ladies 5/10/99 at 18:26
 FA Cup news 21/8/99 at 12:03
 News from France 1/9/99 at 19:37
 Internationals 1/10/99 at 15:56
 Old Boys 5/10/99 at 10:19
 League Cup 1/10/99 at 16:29
 Cybury Gooners 27/9/99 at 11:49
 Shopping news 11/7/01 at 16:18
 


HOME: 06-07, info, history, people, misc, Links | SHOP | Calendar | Table | Stats | FAQs | HELP

copyright belongs to original author where credited. otherwise © Rupert Ward, ArseWeb MMV

ArseWeb is NOT the official Arsenal site. The (excellent) official site is here